The First Automation Most Businesses Get Wrong

Everyone wants to automate. Almost everyone starts in the wrong place. They pick what's visible, not what's painful. Here's how to get it right the first time.

Jeremy Kean

Founder & Business Coach

Everyone Wants to Automate

The appeal is obvious:

  • Less manual work
  • Fewer mistakes
  • More time for what matters

But here's the problem:

Almost everyone starts in the wrong place.

They automate what's visible. Not what's painful.

And that's why most first automations fail.


The Visibility Trap

When business owners think "automation," they usually think about the stuff they see every day:

  • Social media posting
  • Email newsletters
  • Report generation
  • Calendar scheduling

These are visible. They feel automatable.

But here's the question nobody asks:

Is this actually where you're bleeding time?

Often, the answer is no.

The real time-sucks are invisible. They hide in the cracks.


Where the Real Pain Lives

The painful work isn't glamorous. It's:

  • Chasing information: Asking three people for status updates that should be in one place
  • Re-explaining context: Repeating the same background every time you hand something off
  • Manual data entry: Copying information from one system to another
  • Following up: Pinging people to do what they already agreed to do
  • Answering the same questions: Responding to the same client inquiries over and over

These aren't "automation projects." They're friction.

And friction compounds.


The Right Way to Choose Your First Automation

Before you pick a tool, answer these questions:

1. What task do I dread most?

Not "What's tedious?" What makes you groan when it shows up?

Dread is a signal. It means the task is either painful, repetitive, or both.

2. What task has the most handoffs?

Every handoff is a failure point. Information gets lost. Context disappears. Delays stack up.

If a task touches three people before it's done, it's probably a good automation candidate.

3. What task do I do more than 5 times a week?

Frequency matters. Automating something you do once a month isn't worth the setup.

But something you do daily? That's 250+ hours a year. Worth fixing.


The 80% Rule

Your first automation doesn't need to be perfect.

It needs to handle 80% of the cases automatically.

The remaining 20%? You handle manually. For now.

Chasing 100% automation on your first try is how projects die.

Start ugly. Get it working. Refine later.


Real Examples That Actually Work

Instead of: Automating social media posting

Try: Automating the intake form that captures client information so you stop chasing details


Instead of: Building an AI chatbot for your website

Try: Creating a simple FAQ doc and auto-responding to the 10 questions that eat up your inbox


Instead of: Automating report generation

Try: Setting up automatic status updates so you don't have to ask for them


The Compound Effect

Here's what happens when you automate the painful stuff first:

  • You save time immediately (because the pain was real)
  • You build momentum (because the win feels good)
  • You learn what works (because you're solving a real problem)
  • You get buy-in (because your team sees the benefit too)

Start with pain. End with freedom.

That's the path.


Your Move

This week, track your dread.

Every time you think "ugh, I have to do this again", write it down.

By Friday, you'll have a list.

Pick the top one.

That's your first automation.

Not the flashiest. The most painful.

That's where the real leverage lives.

Your next step

Ready to build a business that runs without you?

Take the free Bottleneck Audit to see where you stand, or book a no-pressure Discovery Call with Jeremy.

Straight answers

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What's the most common automation mistake?

    Starting with visible tasks (social media, newsletters) instead of painful tasks (chasing information, manual data entry, repetitive questions). The real time-sucks hide in the cracks, not in the obvious places.

  2. How do I choose my first automation?

    Ask three questions: What task do I dread most? What task has the most handoffs? What task do I do more than 5 times a week? The intersection of dread, complexity, and frequency is where to start.

  3. Does my first automation need to be perfect?

    No. Aim for 80% of cases automated, handle the remaining 20% manually. Chasing perfection on your first try is how automation projects die. Start ugly, get it working, refine later.

  • Automation
  • AI
  • Business Systems
  • Productivity
  • First Steps

This article is part of our

Operations and Fulfillment pillar

How to deliver the work without you being the bottleneck: SOPs, delegation, time, team, and the systems and automation behind them.

Share: